The Impact of Journal Involvement on Availability of Replication Materials (Public)
Project
The Impact of Journal Involvement on Availability of Replication Materials
Study ID sspp-2026-0023-v1
Study Title The Impact of Journal Involvement on Availability of Replication Materials
Authors Jack Fitzgerald, Giovanni Orlando, Arjen van Witteloostuijn
Completion Time 15 Minutes
Close Date (UTC) Sept. 15, 2026
Discipline Management
Field Empirical Research Methodology
Country Online (many countries)
Abstract
I subject the models defending 135 null claims in 81 articles recently published in top economics journals to equivalence testing, which assesses whether an estimate is significantly bounded within a given region around zero. I specifically evaluate how often the models defending these null claims can significantly bound their estimates beneath conventional effect size benchmarks. This survey asks you to make predictions and judgments about equivalence testing failure rates in this sample.
Study ID sspp-2026-0023-v1
Study Title The Impact of Journal Involvement on Availability of Replication Materials
Authors Jack Fitzgerald, Giovanni Orlando, Arjen van Witteloostuijn
Completion Time 15 Minutes
Close Date (UTC) Sept. 15, 2026
Discipline Management
Field Empirical Research Methodology
Country Online (many countries)
Abstract
I subject the models defending 135 null claims in 81 articles recently published in top economics journals to equivalence testing, which assesses whether an estimate is significantly bounded within a given region around zero. I specifically evaluate how often the models defending these null claims can significantly bound their estimates beneath conventional effect size benchmarks. This survey asks you to make predictions and judgments about equivalence testing failure rates in this sample.
Log In to Receive Additional Forecasting Benefits
Save your progress and compare your forecasts to the actual results of the study upon release by logging in.Don't have an account? Sign up here.
Continue without logging in
You can choose to make an account upon completion.